Isle Of Wight Society Opposes ‘Intrusive’ Plans For Historic East Cowes Guardhouse

The Isle of Wight Society has joined calls to refuse what it describes as an ‘intrusive’ proposal to install toilet and shower facilities at a historic building in East Cowes.

The conservation group says there are alternative options to avoid “destroying” the integrity of the Guardhouse at Victoria Barracks on Albany Road, ahead of a decision due on April 29.

Plans submitted by Cowes Harbour Commission include renovation works, new external doors, internal and external alterations, and an extension to the building.

Agents acting on behalf of the commission have previously said the proposals would allow the Isle of Wight Council to improve a building of local importance, support increased footfall in East Cowes and help meet growing demand for maritime facilities.

However, the Isle of Wight Society has objected, arguing the plans would harm the historic value of the site.

In its submission to planners, the group said developments involving heritage assets should focus on conservation and enhancement.

It added the proposals would negatively impact the Guardhouse and fail to respect its relationship with the wider barracks and parade ground.

The society also raised concerns that the changes would be detrimental to the Victorian grouping of the barracks, parade ground, Guardhouse, walls and railings.

Further objections relate to proposed fencing, which the group says would separate the building from its original function within the parade ground.

As an alternative, the society has suggested reopening a disused doorway into a screened area on Columbine Road.

It believes this would still allow the building to be used as a marina shower facility, without requiring berth holders to enter the parade ground.

The group says this approach would enable a more sensitive restoration, including retaining non-opening Victorian-style doors and windows on the parade ground side, while avoiding what it describes as an “unsightly extension”.

It also suggests fewer individual shower units could allow the existing structure to be reused without significant alteration.

A Heritage Statement submitted with the application argues the scheme is appropriate and conservation-led.

It states the proposed conversion, alongside a small side extension, would preserve and enhance the Guardhouse’s heritage value.

The Isle of Wight Council’s public consultation on the application closed on April 7. A decision is expected later this month.